Several years ago, I recommended two stocks in The Oxford Income Letter that generated a lot of reader feedback. I suggested that readers buy stock of a tobacco company that has since been acquired and GEO Group (NYSE: GEO), a private prison operator.
Nearly all of the emails I received about those two stocks were from people angry that I would recommend companies that they considered immoral.
I reminded them that my job is not to impart my values or anyone else’s, but to find the best investments I possibly could. It would then be up to each individual to determine whether it was a good fit for them.
These days, more investors are considering their values when investing. That’s why ESG investing has become so popular. ESG stands for environmental, social and governance. The idea is to invest in companies that treat the environment, customers and employees well.
Assets under management in socially responsible investing strategies are up 25% in four years to $22.9 trillion. That’s trillion, with a “t.” So don’t think that ESG investing is only for tree huggers or your hippie brother-in-law.
And this type of investing is working.
In a study of stock performance from 1982 to 2017, Research Affiliates found that removing stocks that don’t fit into the ESG model has little impact on performance. For example, eliminating fossil fuels from the RAFI U.S. Index improved annual performance by 16 basis points (a basis point is one-hundredth of a percentage point). Removing tobacco led to an underperformance of just eight basis points.
Research Affiliates found similar results in markets outside the U.S.
Dr. Kristin Hull, founder, CEO and CIO of Nia Impact Capital, whose goal is to “design portfolios where financial performance and social impact work hand in hand,” is a leader in socially responsible investing.
She told me, “I find huge opportunities in solving for our earth’s greatest risks, from healthcare, to tropical disease, to sustainable energy issues, to financial inclusion, etc.”
ESG investing can encompass a wide range of companies. It doesn’t have to include only companies with a big social mission like Tesla (Nasdaq: TSLA) or businesses that are trying to save the world.
There are various ways to put money to work according to ESG principles. You can buy ETFs, mutual funds or individual stocks, or you can let a money manager who specializes in this type of strategy invest it for you.
- iShares MSCI USA ESG Select ETF (NYSE: SUSA) is an ETF that aims to track the results of an ESG index.
- Vanguard FTSE Social Index Fund (VFTSX) is a U.S.-focused, socially conscious mutual fund with an ultra-low 0.2% expense ratio. It handily beat the S&P 500 in three of the past five years and is outperforming the S&P again in 2018.
- The tech giant Alphabet (Nasdaq: GOOGL) scores very high on many ESG categories, including a low carbon footprint, water conservation initiatives and gender diversity.
You could also invest with a money manager like the abovementioned Nia Impact Capital or others that have either predesigned or custom ESG portfolios.
Investing with your values doesn’t have to hurt your investing performance. With ESG strategies becoming so popular, there are many ways in which you can put your money to work without owning companies you believe are harmful to the planet or society.
P.S. Have you recently invested in a company that you feel has a strong moral and ethical code, or ruled out a potential investment for moral reasons? If so, we would love to hear your story! Join the conversation by commenting below.