In a recent column, I described how most products in the U.S. became increasingly affordable between 1980 and 2020 when measured in the number of hours worked to pay for them.
However, we saw the biggest spike in inflation in 40 years during the Biden Administration, thanks to massive deficit spending, near-zero interest rates, and the temporary shutdown of the global supply chain.
Yet “time prices” still came down by the end of 2024, extending the long-term trend.
Between 2000 and 2024, the CPI rose 82.2%.
But hourly earnings for blue-collar workers rose 115.1% – outpacing inflation by more than 40%.
That means an hour of work bought 18.1% more goods and services at the end of 2024 than it did at the beginning of 2000.
That’s progress. Just not the kind that the media bothers to cover.
Unlike money, time can’t be counterfeited or inflated.
There is perfect equality here. We all get 60 minutes in an hour and 24 hours in a day.
Our time is truly our most precious resource, the only one that cannot be recycled, stored, duplicated, or recovered.
When time prices decrease – as they have for decades now – an hour of time buys more products and services.
While people often compare what they make with someone earning more, they rarely stop to realize how much more they can buy today compared with what they could buy in the past for the same hours worked.
Time prices are the one unimpeachable standard to compare abundance from one era to another.
And their fall is not due to an increase in material resources. It is due to the expansion of knowledge, which enables us to use resources more creatively and effectively.
This is a powerful phenomenon, yet one that is not commonly understood.
Being able to afford more while working less is further evidence that most Americans are living the Dream without realizing it.
Most of us take the long-term improvement in our standard of living for granted.
Indeed, there is a common misconception that increasing progress and prosperity have been the norm for as long as human beings have been around.
Yet history reveals that this is decidedly not the case.
Imagine, for example, that the Roman statesman Cicero was magically able to time travel and visit Thomas Jefferson at Monticello more than 1,800 years later.
Cicero would arrive at the coast of Virginia the same way Jefferson would have made the trip to Italy.
He would ride a horse to the nearest port and trust his fate to a windblown ship.
When Cicero arrived at Monticello months later, things would look quite familiar.
Jefferson’s home was heated by fire in the winter, and the doors and windows were left wide open in the summer, the same as in ancient Rome.
Jefferson read by candlelight, drew his water from a well, ate mostly what he raised, used an outhouse, and owned slaves, just like Romans did 18 centuries earlier.
Cicero would learn that four of Jefferson’s six children did not survive early childhood.
Nothing new there. This was sadly the case for most of human history.
(Jefferson’s wife died at age 33 of complications from giving birth to their sixth child.)
Except for a few notable innovations – like the printing press, gunpowder, and the compass – life in 1800 was hardly distinguishable from life almost 2,000 years earlier.
Since then, however, there has been an explosion in human progress and prosperity.
Economic historian Deirdre McCloskey calls it the Great Enrichment, a period of exponential wealth creation that started more than 200 years ago and is still accelerating.
This is plainly visible in the quality of your transportation, the speed of your communications, your many laborsaving devices, and the huge variety of goods, services, and outright luxuries available to you at the click of a button.
Thomas Jefferson did not have electricity, cars, trains, airplanes, radio, television, cameras and video recorders, smartphones, computers, lasers, batteries, the World Wide Web, antibiotics, vaccines, pacemakers, artificial hearts, MRI scans, gene therapies, and countless other lifesaving and life-enhancing innovations.
What is most responsible for our exponential increase in abundance?
Two things: freedom and people.
Freedom is crucial because it allows people to create and profit from their innovations.
(That’s why goods and services have not become cheaper for the average consumer in Cuba, Venezuela, North Korea, and other unfree nations.)
But this phenomenon is not about freedom alone. It’s also about more people. A lot more people.
People generate knowledge. Knowledge multiplies output. And freedom lets people share, trade, and profit from their discoveries.
The freer a society, the greater its time price gains. The more people it empowers, the richer its outcomes.
Scarcity didn’t win. Innovation did.
We have increased food supply, for instance, by increasing yields from existing fields.
We’ve increased our agricultural efficiency so much that less than 2% of the U.S. population farms at all.
After more than a century of intensive fossil fuel use, we have more known deposits of oil and gas than ever before.
(And we’ve surveyed only a tiny portion of the planet.)
Overpopulation is not a threat. On the contrary, limiting population growth limits brainpower.
Yet generations of schoolchildren have been taught that population growth makes resources scarcer.
Indeed, academia and the media repeatedly warn us that we are consuming the planet’s natural resources at an alarming rate… and that they will soon be gone.
Not true. Resource abundance is growing faster than the world population.
Our economy has reached such a level of efficiency and sophistication that we are producing an increasing amount of goods and services while using ever-fewer resources.
For example, from 2014 to 2024 U.S. real gross domestic product grew by 27.6%.
But, over the same period, energy consumption decreased by 1.3%.
Western countries have learned how to get the most energy with the least emission of greenhouse gases.
As we climbed the energy ladder from wood to coal to oil to gas, the ratio of carbon to hydrogen in our energy sources fell steadily.
As a result, fewer American cities are now shrouded in a smoggy haze.
Our distant ancestors spent most of their waking hours hunting and gathering food to live.
Yet the typical American today earns their food in a matter of minutes. And we are spoiled for choice at the average supermarket.
We have more goods and services available – and work fewer hours to afford them – than any previous generation.
The world today is incomparably richer than it was in decades past.
Yet the doomsayers are unable to see it – or don’t want to.
Instead, they continually warn us that the end is nigh.
As a result, many Americans are unable to enjoy the countless advantages of modern life because they believe it is on the verge of ending – and there is nothing they can do about it.
Don’t buy it. Especially the claims about “overpopulation.”
The most important resource in today’s world is not oil or natural gas or some rare earth mineral.
It’s people. By applying their intelligence and creativity, individual men and women make other resources more abundant.
Additional people don’t just create additional demand. (Although that also promotes growth and prosperity.)
They represent an additional supply of ideas, knowledge, and productive work.
We shouldn’t underestimate the power of this. Or what time prices tell us.
When you spend less time laboring to feed and clothe your family, put a roof over your head, keep the lights on, and pay your bills, you are gaining the ultimate wealth: more time to do what you really want.
This is not just prosperity. It’s superabundance.
And another reason to acknowledge that the American Dream is alive and well – for those with eyes to see it.
Beautiful brilliant essay
I really enjoyed your article. I believe like you do that there is way too much brain washing bs people who step back and think for themselves. Thank you. Happy New Year !
It is popular for wealthy people to blame Joe Biden for inflation. You should tell the truth and leave politics out of your comments. Inflation hit over 9% due to the global pandemic and Donald Trump administration failure to tell the truth about the pandemic. Joe Biden inherited that mess from Donald Trump and then worked inflation down to 3%. Donald Trump and his administration have kept inflation high by charging taxes (he calls Tariffs) on US importers of goods. Blame the pandemic if you will, but don’t assign blame to Joe Biden who worked to clean up the mess that Trump tried to ignore.
Hurray for you. I am repeatedly delighted with your meaningful and insightful comments. I am an old man in good health who has been given the wonderful opportunity to care for my totally disabled precious wife. My dominant emotion? Gratitude. God and many, many others have provided me with an abundance of good things all my life. Thank you for your wonderful reminders of what is important.
My choices have decreased in the supermarket. Finding food untainted by multiple toxins has reduced product to less than 1% of what is displayed. I read labels carefully. The typical product has multiple chemicals and ingredients that are completely unnatural. Regulation favors systems that are about appearance and shelf life when what should be promoted are naturally dense nutrients with nothing added.
Please help me understand the math “But hourly earnings for blue-collar workers rose 115.1% – outpacing inflation by more than 40%.” If in 2020 I was making $110K and in 2023 I was making $189K annually, how does that get 115% increase. That’s an 80% increase. Then I go to the simple check of groceries. In 2020 I was buy weekly for a family of 4 $125 to 160 per week, now in 2024 groceries for Two was 280 to 300 per week Based o this I am paying more per hour not less. I would say the the lower middle class (still blue collar) were in the same boat. It could be the geographical region that is skewing the data, but its not a fit for me. My pay increase in 24 years rose 80% and groceries rose 120%, a flip to your data.
I’ve been reading your articles for a while now, and love the facts on how you compare then and now. I’m sure this is unknown to a lot of people, as it was to me…so I pass them on. Keep them coming
Great article Alex.Thankyou.
True to the point Alex Now we got to get people to live it
Happy New Year
another year like the last one
and many more
GOD BLESS & Happy New Year
To all at the Oxford club
GENE JANSSEN
This is intriguing and would be tempting if it weren’t blatantly tilted politically. E.g., Inflation during the Biden years was not significantly driven by “massive deficit spending.” In fact, federal deficits were far greater under Trump 1 (and are greatly increasing again in Trump 2) than they were under Biden. The disrupted supply chains caused by the pandemic and low interest rates necessitated by exploding unemployment were far and away the dominant causes, and inflation quickly came down as supply chains opened up and economic activity returned to more normal. You make it very clear that you are a strong Trump supporter, which turns off a lot of folks like me. I can’t trust you or your judgment, even if what you are selling would be a great investment, because you clearly see the world through distorted political lenses. Just make your pitch without revealing your extreme political perspectives that over half of Americans reject. You’ll probably be more successful.
Alex Green is that rare historian (and investor)!! His work is always interesting and pertinent — and often counter-cultural (Doomsayers give it up, take breather from spreading your lies).